Free Estimate

Infinity Roofing Reviews: See what your neighbors have to say about our work

"Reputation before profit." Our motto at Infinity Roofing contrasts with most Wisconsin roofing contractors. We want to develop lasting relationships with our customers and not simply move on to the next job. Our goal is to educate you about the project and let you make the decision to hire us. We are confident that when you know the facts....we are the best option! We've completed over 20,000 jobs in Wisconsin. See what our customers have to say about our exceptional roof installation and repair services. For excellent roof installation in Appleton, Milwaukee, Madison, or anywhere in Wisconsin, contact the expert roofers at Infinity Exteriors, LLC.

"Steve, the service person from the Appleton location, did an outstanding job in fixing things that had needed attention. Prompt, courteous, efficient and most helpful. We were very impressed with his professional service."

Betty Stevens

"Outstanding service. We are so pleased. You truly walk the talk for customer service - cleanup, workmanship, conscientiousness! Two workers actually thanked me for giving them work!! Doug, the foreman, stayed until dumpster left. Even we left before that. We'll talk in spring about windows!

Thank you so much!"

5 out of 5 stars!

"I cannot thank you enough for the wonderful work that was done on my roof. The workers were just outstanding and the workmanship is top-quality. Thanks especially to Doug for dealing with the unexpected problems. Thanks to Josh for talking me into contracting with him. I don't think any other company would have even come close to the workmanship and the dedicated workers. (a raise for all of them) Thanks again for everything.

P.S. I’ve been giving your name to people in need of your services!!!"

"These guys really hustled from the moment they got here. There was camaraderie between all of them. They did an excellent job of cleaning up while they were working and when they finished went around umpteen times checking to be sure that there was no debris left. Thanks for everything"

"Clean-up was hampered by a down pour. They (Milwaukee roofing contractors) did a very good job even in less than perfect conditions. Thank you very much. Hope to use your services again."

Unbelievable, simply the best. Accommodating, professional, exemplary performance. From my first initial phone call with Julia to Josh, MJ, Mike, and his crew thing could not possibly have run any better. You are a well-oiled machine.


We are so happy with the job your company did. The entire process was easy because of the communication with MJ and Julia. The crew started early and worked late (seemed to on our end) to finish it all in the day. They went the extra step to cover and protect our yard and clean up after including offering to move patio furniture and grills. We will definitely recommend Infinity to everyone! Thank You!

Ali and Brian

Really marvelous crews. They all deserve bonuses. They have my thanks. Gutters have not yet had an opportunity to “show their stuff”, but they look handsome! Your firm represents the very best elements of American Small Businesses.

To Joshua Sparks,

Just wanted you to know how pleased we are with our new roof Infinity installed on our home. Your (Milwaukee roofing) workmen were very courteous and installed everything just the way we wanted it. They cleaned up everything after they finished.

Thanks for the great job you did, each and every one of you.

Thanks for everything, you did a great job. Special Thanks to the man who refastened the Dish on the roof - it works better than it ever did! He deserves special praise since he was doing that as the “blizzard” set in! We will definitely recommend your (Waukesha roofing) company.”

I was very pleased with the result.

Excellent. I got three estimates. Infinity was the lowest in cost, but Josh Sparks gave an excellent presentation and explanation of what would be done. His method sounded just like the very high end estimate I received from another contractor. The job was done as described, on time and I was very pleased with the result. Also enjoyed working with everyone from Infinity.

Very professional. From the moment I called for an estimate to the completion of the work. Josh, the estimator, showed up at precisely the time he said he would. He described the company and its origins. He explained the product, product options, the installation process, the debris removal process, the work crews and how they operated, the guarantees and warranties, everything one would need to know in order to make an informed decision. Very professional. He also explained that because of the backlog of jobs they had scheduled, he could not give me an exact start date. He gave me an "about date" that turned out to be very close to the actual start date. The work crew was absolutely fantastic. They arrived around 8 a.m. and at 1 or 2 p.m. the job was completely finished. They explained that they had a double crew on this job, and normally it takes two days to complete a job. Each member of the crew knew his job and went about it with clock-like precision. When the job was completed, the entire crew did a walk-around the grounds looking for anything that was out of order or had been missed. I was very impressed. This is a 5-star company with the highest recommendation.

We would use this company again and highly recommend it to others. Signed proposal on 5/14/08 and roof was installed on 5/29/08. The very professional crew was polite and courteous at all times. They worked from early morning until 6:30 PM. They even nailed down loose shingles on our decorative wishing well in the yard. They used a magnet tool to sweep the driveway for loose or scattered nails on the ground. Mary Jean Sparks was always very responsive and helpful to all our phone calls and helped us to send appropriate papers to the shingle manufacturer for a rebate under warranty.

I contacted Infinity through a referral from someone at work. I scheduled an appointment with the courteous office staff, and Josh arrived on time and was prepared. Josh was very professional and friendly. He explained everything, was able to answer all of our questions, and left us feeling that we knew what to expect. The week before our job was to begin we received a call from the office, informing us about the material and the dumpster deliveries, and the start date for the work. The roof was completed in one day, much to our surprise. The clean up and crew were excellent. The siding and gutters took about a week to finish and turned out great. I was amazed at the amount of work they got done professionally in such a short amount of time. Infinity kept in contact with us during the process to make sure we were happy. The project was completed and we were left with a new home. The neighborhood liked our new look too!!

It was great from start to finish. Darryl the person who did the estimate was nice, professional and always returned my calls in a timely manner. He also answered my questions thoroughly. The roof on our 3 buildings were torn down and replaced in a 1 1/2 days. The workers were friendly and professional. They did a great job and cleaned up very well.

The Milwaukee roofing crew arrived per schedule and finished the complete roof repair job in one day. The installers were professional and did a good job installing and cleaning up. We are pleased with the job.

The Infinity crew did a very nice job. Having had roofing done on this home and other properties in the past, I believe that Infinity did an excellent job at a very fair price. I'd been concerned that a low pitch area might again develop leaks through the ice & water shield, because we'd had galvanized nails rust and shrink after being in wet ice damming. Josh agreed to use copper nails in that area to eliminate the possibility of rust. Infinity's 8 man crew completed most of the job in one day, with two men doing the finish work the following day. The dumpster was only here for 24 hours and the crew was careful working around our plants and flowers. Josh agreed to re-pitch a gutter and have it discharge to the opposite side of the house. He also found downspouts to match the siding color rather than using just white downspout material.

Infinity Exteriors did the roofs for my condo development, 5 buildings. They did a great job. It was a pleasure working with Nick during the quoting process. Scott did a great job managing the project. I would definitely recommend Infinity Exteriors!

Sarah Oberhofer

Adam Landwehr is doing an excellent job in assisting us with replacement windows for our historic Delafield home.

James A. Nelson

This company takes care of their customers, even when the roof needed minor repairs after 9 years. I would recommend them again and again.

Bill Brockman

Working with Infinity Exteriors has been great so far. Our salesman Tom was very attentive and worked around our schedule without complaint. We felt we got honest answers and were never pushed. We are very much looking forward to having them do our windows and siding project.

Nalleli Luevano

Tom has been great to work with through the process of choosing windows and siding. I would recommend him to others.

Debbie Moczyns

Good, honest company that does prompt and quality work with good products. I have had them do two projects, some new construction windows and flashing an old deck while replacing a patio door. Both were done quickly and they resolved any issues as they worked. With the cold temps we've had early on I am very glad I had this done, and the products are noticeably superior to the original windows I still have in other areas of the home. I am looking forward to having them all done eventually.

Michael Daly

Great roofing and exterior company to work with, very professional, knowledgeable and responsive. Trevor and Jim took care of everything, explained the entire process from start to finish, and worked with our insurance company to make sure our hail damaged roof would be fully covered. Highly recommend!

Milwaukee Roofing Customer

Sean’s roofing crew was on time and very professional. They did a great roof replacement and even did a great job cleaning up in the dark with headlamps and magnets. Highly recommended.

Milwaukee Roofing Customer

Victor was amazing and explained everything to us and was very honest with us. Joe and his team were awesome, completed the work very efficiently, and did the best clean up I have ever seen. Any small issues that happened were fixed right away the next morning. No complaints. Best home repair experience I have had!!! The roof is beautiful and my yard was cleaner than before they started the work! I cannot say enough good things about this company!!!

Appleton Roofing Customer

We are very happy with the new roof and gutters that were installed! I can’t say enough about the professionalism and quality of work and materials that Infinity performed for us. They were on time, performed everything that was promised, completely cleaned up when they were done. The work crew that installed our roof was amazing, I have never seen a more dedicated , hard working group of people! We would highly recommend infinity to anyone.

Happy Appleton Roofing Customer

The whole team was professional and responsive. We got continual updates both before and during and after our roof replacement. Highly recommend.

Madison Roofing Customer

Our whole town got nailed with a vicious storm. Vin came out and surveyed the damage done to our roof and gutters. He made the whole insurance process easy and stress free. He answered all my questions and I look forward to working with him for years to come.

Madison Roofing Customer

Had a great experience with Infinity Exteriors from start to finish. Worked with a few different staff members but with Caleb and Jake the most who were both fantastic. We needed our siding replaced due to cracking and buckling etc. Every meeting we had with the team that supported us was comfortable, easy, and informative. Highly recommend using Infinity for your needs.

Roby Skrbis

Infinity Exteriors recently replaced the windows on our home. The experience was exceptional. The sales process, measuring, installation, and follow-up during and after the project were professional and well done. The windows look great on our house...

Mike Faschingbauer

I used Infinity for two different roofing jobs on my home in Milwaukee: a standard asphalt/shingle roof and a flat roof using tpo and aluminum through wall scuppers. I found that Infinity was extremely professional throughout the entire process, from initial consultation, to install and through final punch-out of details and payment.

Ryan Shortridge

Infinity is my go-to contractor for exterior needs. As the Maintenance Director for area luxury apartment communities I have had them repair damaged fascia, replace the shingled roofs on 8 buildings with 33 apartments per building, and I am currently using them to replace windows in that same community. The thing that makes them stand out from other contractors (besides competitive pricing), is their customer service. Jake K. goes above and beyond to make sure everything is right from the first meeting about a project, to any follow-up and service needed after the jobs are complete. When it comes to doing the job, the installers workmanship is of the highest quality and they get the job done in a timely matter. All while keeping it clean to be as minimally intrusive to our residents as possible. I have referred Infinity to family and friends for window and roofing work on their homes. Jake takes the time to explain their products and the process so that his customer understands and is comfortable with their decision to use Infinity. I look forward to working with Jake and Infinity for more projects in the future.

Andy Schalk

Infinity Exteriors personnel is very professional and knowledgeable, I had a great experience from the first call I made to them to request an estimate for roof repair until the last email they send for the follow up. Ty, the Project Coordinator, was very courteous and detailed, I also received an estimate on gutters replacement which I definitely need to do. Very pleased with the experience and I will definitely will use them for future needs.

Sasha Demian

My wife and I are extremely happy that we chose Infinity Exteriors for our roof, gutters, windows, and attic insulation. Jason Strekow has done an exceptional job of educating us on our job, keeping in contact and keeping us informed. If you are reading this review and trying to decide what company to go with, you will not be disappointed with how you are taken care of at Infinity. Thanks Jason!

Michael Isler

We had our roof, gutters and skylights replaced by Infinity. The crew completed our project in two days and we were so impressed with every member of the Infinity team from the office, our sales person Mike Wolf, project manager Jim Flowers to the roofing and gutter installers. The quality, workmanship and cost sealed the deal for us and we recommend Infinity to be number one on your list of contractors.

Mary L

We had our house totally resided, doors and windows replaced this year. We couldn't be happier with the results. Jake, the project coordinator, was very helpful with discussing the project regarding cost and selection of materials. There was no high pressure sales pitch. Nick and J.R., the project managers, were very hands on and accommodating throughout the project. They addressed any unexpected problems or changes to our complete satisfaction. Ian, the project foreman, with his crew was there every day and went over and above anything we could have expected. We cannot say enough about Infinity's work. Mark and Judy

Judy Swokowski

I would recommend infinity to anyone! From the minute Vin was assigned to our project we knew he was our guy! Unlike the other companies we tried to work with- Vin answered every email, text and phone call timely and never made me feel like I was bothering him! Thank you Vin and Infinity Roofing- you have found yourself a life long customer!

Kaylin Hetts

Vin really knew his stuff and was able to make the process very thorough and simple at the same time. He went above and beyond with his service, helping secure some siding while he was inspecting the roof damage to help prevent leaks. We loved his energy, passion and recommendations! Communication was also very timely and easy to understand. You can tell Vin and his team have a ton of experience and have really fine tuned their processes to benefit their customer. They also back their quality which is a huge benefit of working with them.

Elysha Lamping

We needed 4 awning windows replaced and received quotes from 7 other window companies and ultimately decided to go with Infinity due to their extremely competitive pricing, warranty and outstanding customer service. Having met with several other companies, Zac was a breath of fresh air and did not put any pressure on us to make a quick decision (vs. other companies that offer 'great' deals but you must commit the day of the estimate). Zac was extremely responsive and addressed all of our questions, ensuring we were comfortable throughout the whole process. The installation done in one day and we are very happy with our new windows!

Caroline Murphy

We were extremely pleased with the roofing replacement Infinity Exteriors did for us! Charlie got our job ready and on the schedule quickly. Our project manager Matt kept us informed through the entire process. They were professional, courteous and attentive to our needs. The roofing Installation was done expertly. One of the major selling points for us was that it comes with an extensive 50 year, transferrable warranty. Thank you for a job well done!

Terese Braatz

We had a new roof, siding, windows and insulation all done with Infinity. Jake K is exceptional at what he does but doesn’t try to oversell you on anything. Infinity wasn’t our lowest priced quote but my gut feeling was to go with them and I’m so glad we did! My two year old daughter even loved having “all of the guys” working there on the various projects! We are pleased with the final project and so happy we went with Infinity!

Sarah Kaepernick

I used Infinity exteriors to install both siding and gutters. I worked with Caleb (sales), Nick (project manager), and Lorenzo (crew leader). My home turned out beautiful, and I'm not the easiest guy to please. Infinity may be a larger contractor, but I was treated like I was their only customer. Caleb, Nick, Lorenzo and his crew were awesome to work with and they really cared about their job and making sure I was satisfied with their work.

Richard Kemmel

Tom guided us through the process so well we’ve used him twice for a roof installation. He listened to our situation both experiences and customized the approach to fit our budget and goals. The peace of mind that comes with partnering on large projects like this with Infinity Exteriors is worth its weight in gold. The warranty is unmatched and the quality of materials are unparalleled. We wouldn’t recommend or choose any other option when it comes to this important decision.

Kristine Howell

We had our siding and gutters done by Infinity back in April and we are extremely pleased with the whole experience. Jason was great. Answered all our questions and helped us with any concerns we had. Made the buying experience a good one. We also can’t say enough about the crew. Fast, efficient, and very friendly. They did an outstanding job!

Al Nogalski

Victor was amazing and explained everything to us and was very honest with us. Joe and his team were awesome, completed the work very efficiently, and did the best clean up I have ever seen. Any small issues that happened were fixed right away the next morning. No complaints. Best home repair experience I have had!!! The roof is beautiful and my yard was cleaner than before they started the work! I cannot say enough good about this company!!!

Heather Dryer

Infinity Exteriors is a GREAT company. Infinity replaced a flat roof on my company’s building and also did the new flat roof on an addition. Both great value and meticulous work.

Steven R Libbey

Excellent customer service. We had our roof and attic thoroughly inspected by Mike with Infinity Roofing and we plan to use this company to get our home back in tip top shape! Mike found hail damage, leaking around the chimney, etc....and we had suspected as much due to water marks on ceilings in various rooms. Infinity was highly recommended by neighbors and friends.

Kristen Paulson

We are very happy with the new roof and gutters that were installed! I can’t say enough about the Professionalism and quality of work and materials that infinity perform for us. They were on time, performed everything that was promised, completely cleaned up when they were done. The work crew that installed our roof was amazing, I have never seen a more dedicated , hard working group of people! We would highly recommend infinity to anyone.

Jim Truman

I contracted with Infinity Exteriors LLC to replace the siding on the gable-ends of my brick ranch. From the start, it was easy to schedule an estimate using the company's website. Isaac, my estimator, did an excellent job explaining the available products and presented a fair price. The crew of 8 workers arrived on time. They removed the old siding and cleaned up the area around the house, leaving it immaculate. The carpentry crew expertly applied the new siding and touched up any areas where the surface was scratched. The project manager, Mike, did a walk-through after completion and made sure that I was completely satisfied. The finished project turned out beyond my expectations. I would not hesitate to call on Infinity for any future exterior projects.

Justin Mayer

We had our flat roof replaced by Infinity Exteriors and they did an excellent job. The project itself was a big deal and they handled it without any issues. Everyday the crew would cleanup the site and make sure their materials were not littered on the property. I could not see everything they were doing on the roof, but I could tell they sure knew what they were doing. I would recommend Infinity to anyone that is considering a project. From the first meeting with Adam to the last day of the project, I was totally impressed with Infinity.

Tom Hauser

I used Infinity Exteriors to replace my roof as well as 11 windows in the fall of 2020. Not only did they have the best warranty but also had the most competitive pricing of the companies I received quotes from. The roof installation only took about a day and a half, while the windows took about two days to install. Both experiences were great, the crews were professional, on-time, and cleaned up everything. Having experienced winter with the new windows and roof I've seen a decrease by about $20 per month on average. I would call them again for other home projects and would recommend them to anyone in need of a roof or windows. They don't pressure you to buy they simply let the product speak for itself.

Michael Tweedy

I used Infinity for two different roofing jobs on my home in Milwaukee: a standard asphalt/shingle roof and a flat roof using tpo and aluminum through wall scuppers. I found that Infinity was extremely professional throughout the entire process, from initial consultation, to install and through final punch-out of details and payment.

Ryan Shortridge

Serving Wisconsin

Madison Area

Appleton Area

Oh no!

JavaScript is required for full site functionality.