Skip to main content

Infinity Roofing Reviews: See what your neighbors have to say about our work

"Reputation before profit." Our motto at Infinity Roofing contrasts with most Wisconsin and Illinois roofing contractors. We want to develop lasting relationships with our customers and not simply move on to the next job. Our goal is to educate you about the project and let you make the decision to hire us. We are confident that when you know the facts....we are the best option! We've completed over 48,000 jobs in Wisconsin and Illinois. See what our customers have to say about our exceptional roof installation and repair services. For excellent roof installation in Wisconsin and Illinois, contact the expert roofers at Infinity Exteriors, LLC.

We could not have hoped or dreamed for a better experience of replacing our original asbestos tile roof. Research and obtaining bids from 5 or 6 companies was a very confusing task involving a spreadsheet. Joe Standish was truly outstanding in educating us on all the important matters in roofing, and was delightful to deal with. Our project was managed by Scotty, who wrote the book on professionalism, efficiency and attention to detail. Our job, originally expected to take 2 - 3 weeks, was completed in 5 work days. We received many compliments from passers-by on not only our beautiful new roof, but about the courtesy and professionalism of the crew. Since then, Infinity has helped us on three other projects for old home repairs and improvements. We are very happy with the results and highly recommend Infinity Exteriors.

Diane Campion

We couldn't be happier about our entire experience with Infinity! They were all so helpful, professional, and detail oriented. We knew exactly what we were getting with our siding project thanks to the extensive mock-ups, meetings, and notes with Isaac; our project manager, Jake, was always available to answer any questions; Harley and Isaac checked in each day during the installation too to make sure things were running smoothly; and the crew was so hardworking and meticulous! It was a wonderful experience working with this company, their quality of work is unmatched, and we would 100% recommend them!

Lindsey Deacon

We encountered Nick Morn, Dir. of Business Development, at Infinity Exteriors in 2015, when we needed one section of our three section roof replaced. The crew worked like a military operation with its own logistics provider. Materials were brought to the house on a pallet and everything needed was on site when the crew arrived. The work done in 2015 was so good, we called Nick in to look at another section of roof we wanted done. Figured if we did a section every 5 years, the cost for replacement wouldn't kill us financially. We wanted a ridge vent put on both sections of roof and we wanted to add more insulation to the attic on the top section of the house (Infinity added insulation to the other 2 sections of the roof previously). Nick gave us an unbelievable price to do both sections rather than the one and insulation could be added prior to putting the new roof on by cutting a hole through the roof boards and patched back up. No hoses or insulation was dragged through the house.

Crew showed up on June 4 to start the work and they hoped it would be a one day job. Ended up being too hot out and they needed frequent water breaks. The end of the work day, we figured they'd wrap it up around 5pm and we had to meet friends for dinner and left. We returned at 8:30pm and the crew was still here working on the roof. They waited until the sun went down and made significant progress. They didn't leave here until 9pm. They finished up the next day and also repaired a rotted corner of overhang on my garage and cut in 5 more overhang vents to help the ridge vent draw. The work was done as efficiently in 2020 as it was in 2015. The job coordinator kept us involved every step of the way and when the job was done, he went up to inspect it and took pictures of the work and emailed them to me, right down to the new chimney flashing.

In short, given the quality and reasonable costs for the work Infinity Exteriors does, there was no alternative than to bring them in for the additional work I needed. If you need work done on your home, from windows to roofing, no need to look any further than Infinity Exteriors.

January 8, 2022: I am a repeat customer of Infinity Exteriors and had need for more repair to be done on my house. Toward the end of summer, I saw what looked like a hole in some soffit fascia trim near the edge of a gutter and saw bees flying in and out of the hole. Didn't know how far that hole went in or whether bees had access to the attic or not. Caleb Coslet came out to look at the damage and suggested we replace the soffit fascia on the rear upper gable of the house with LP Smart Siding and it could be painted at the shop prior to installation. He also found another 5 foot section on the back end of the house on the roof that needed replacing as well. The work was done on December 27, 2021 by Eric. We just had a snowfall and it was a bit cold that day. Eric was the only crew person. The old trim was torn off and new installed. No more bees, no hole, and the LP Smart Siding should last close to forever. I don't think there is anything involving the outside of a home that Infinity Exteriors can't fix. Great job !!

Update: March 13, 2025: We needed siding on our house replaced due to it being original cedar from back in 1969. Siding sustained massive sun damage and the stain was about all that held it together. As usual, we contacted Infinity Exteriors. Dan Miller came out and provided us with an estimate. Jake Fails was the project manager. Roughly 2/3 of our house was re-sided with LP SmartSiding that was custom colored to match the siding we didn't replace. The project started a week ago and a crew of 10 showed up from Bonilla's Siding, a sub-contracted group ? Within 2 hours, all the siding was torn off the house. New special wrap went up and the board & batten siding began, with every batten board caulked top, bottom, and sides. The entire job was almost knocked out the first day. Crew worked 7:30 to 3:30 on a Saturday to finish the project and looks great. Thanks, Infinity ! Happy 10th anniversary with us !!

S Tentoni

We enjoyed working with Jason on our siding and window project! We are moving forward with the proposal and are looking forward to working with Jason and Brandon!

Erica Ingbretson

We had 9 windows replaced the crew was experienced and professional. They respected our property by using shoe covers in the house. Everything was done neatly and carefully to prevent any damage to window openings. Once windows were in the trim and casings were neatly installed. Very professional work. We would recommend their business. Sales people and project manager were very nice and followed through with inspection of installation. Thank you

Sally Kamperschroer

We had a big project of replacing our siding, most of our windows, and two main doors. Received quotes from three vendors and decided to go with Infinity due to competitive pricing, the thorough details in the quote, and our comfort level with David, the salesman. We were told it might take a long time for materials to arrive (sign of the times) but we're pleasantly surprised when they arrived faster than anticipated. We are very happy with the end result, it looks like we have a brand new house!
There are a few small things that would have me give this a 4.5 star review if it were possible to give half stars. The dumpster was parked in the middle of our driveway for over a week and some materials were in the way of our garage some days, so it was difficult to park our cars. Not a big deal, except we had a smaller crew working, so the project took a while and being winter it was inconvenient . There was also a lot of garbage, nails, etc around the yard at completion. It was explained to us that it's difficult to pick up scraps in the winter with snow and getting dark earlier. It just seemed like a lot of nails (probably 50 or more) to be along the perimeter of our house and we picked them up ourselves. They did eventually send someone back to clean up a few days after completion. Overall though, we are very happy with the end result.

Catherine Kienast

We had a fantastic experience with Infinity Exteriors! Mike Keller and Prada were so attentive! They answered all our questions, quotes and subsequent change orders FAST! And when I was second guessing colors for the second, third, fourth time (LOL) Mike calmly talked me off the ledge. He even helped me find a solution for the gable trim we wanted. It's a 107 year old home so not much is standard or square! The trim he assisted me with finding is gorgeous!

Nancy Hollenbeck

We had a fantastic experience working with Jon M! He was professional, knowledgeable and helpful through the bid process on our siding project. He took the time to explain our options so we felt confident in our decision. We are excited to get our project going with Infinity!

Andrea Scrobel